Car repairs vs. car payments



I mentioned previously that my husband’s car needs some repairs and some maintenance — probably around $2000 worth in total, although he will be pricing them at various places, so that number may go down.

What’s surprised me are the reactions of the people’s he’s told about the work his car needs done.

Many of them have responded with things like “Time to get a new car!” or “So are you getting a new car?”.

He says “No, I like not having a car payment.” or “No, it’s much less to repair it than to get a new one.”

I suspect many people think “Two thousand dollars! This car’s gonna put me in the poor house!” instead of thinking “Well, if that’s all the repairs & maintenance it needs this year, that averages out to $166.67 per month for the year.”

Now sure, if his car needed $2000 worth of work constantly, he’d consider replacing the car, but the likelihood of that is (thankfully) not very high. And all cars need maintenance.

As an example, the last time I calculated it I’d spent about $28,000 total on my car over the 17 years I had owned it to that point. That figure includes the $12,000 purchase price — which was pretty darn expensive back in 1991 for a used car — but does not include gas or insurance.

I found data (from 2006) on the FTC site that says, “According to the National Automobile Dealers Association, the average price of a new car sold in the United States is $28,400.” Finance that whole amount over 72 months and you get a monthly payment of $499.57.

If I’d bought a new car every time my car needed a $1000, $2000, or $3500 repair, I’d have bought about 7 new cars by now. Even if I’d only bought a new car every 7 years, I’d have bought two additional new cars by now. A total of 3 “average” new cars is a whole lot more than $28,000.

Dave Ramsey said recently that “a car payment is a guarantee you’ll stay middle class”.

I think he’s got something there. Just think what investing that money instead can accomplish.

Related Websites
  • Save Time, Money and Space in Over 80 Ways If you're looking for handy gadgets, tools and various items that can save you time, money or space (or all three!) this list of more...
  • Why Invest? Do you have some money socked away, or are you planning to sock some money away for the purpose of investing? Are you wondering why...
  • Figure the interest Johnny Carson once said, "Scientists have discovered a powerful new weapon that leaves buildings standing, but destroys people . . . it is called the...

Posted in Credit cards & loans on Aug 05, 2009

5 Responses to “ Car repairs vs. car payments ”

  1. # 1 Clifford Says:

    I faced the exact same situation earlier this year. Repairs were around $1,100 and people instantly started saying that it was time for a new car. Considering it was the first $1,100 paid in 2 years I had to question their sanity.

  2. # 2 Craig Says:

    Maybe per month, but that’s also assuming there won’t be more maintenance throughout the year.

  3. # 3 bluntmoney Says:

    Clifford, glad we’re not the only ones.

    Craig, yes, but maintenance is easy to predict since it’s usually done on a schedule.

  4. # 4 dawn Says:

    I love that Dave Ramsey quote.

    I’m with you. I drive a 10-yr-old Honda and hope to get at least a few more years out of it.

    I wrote an interesting blog post about my total car ownership costs to date. I’m a pretty good record-keeper, so these numbers aren’t calculations; they’re 100% accurate. I included everything: the purchase price, car insurance, maintenance and repairs and gasoline.

    http://credit-blog.creditfyi.com/personal-finances/the-true-cost-of-owning-a-car.html

  5. # 5 bluntmoney Says:

    Dawn, that was an interesting breakdown. It makes me want to calculate the actual total cost of ownership for my car too. Although sadly I don’t have gas broken out separately from my ex’s cars for several years, so it’s impossible.


  • bluntmoney.com