Is it really about how you pay?
NCN wrote recently about How to Break the Credit Card Habit, and he said something I thought was really interesting:
“I’ve heard it a thousand times — ‘If I have cash in my pocket, I’ll just spend it.’ That might be true, if you still have your credit card to fall back on. On the other hand, if you knew, and I mean knew, that the cash in your pocket was all that you had, I’ll be that you could learn to manage it.”
My first thought was, wow, he’s right. Cash normally runs through my hands like water, but if I only had $10 in my pocket, and it was my last $10, of course I wouldn’t blow it on lunch out or some snacks. I’d probably buy some eggs, a loaf of bread, and a stack of Top Ramen instead to get enough food for a week or two of minimal meals.
I use credit cards all the time now. For a while I didn’t use them at all (relying instead on checks and my debit card) because I never wanted to owe money on them again. In other words, I didn’t trust myself to use them responsibly.
Cash still runs through my hands like water, but I pay off my credit cards in full each month. (And sometimes within hours of making a purchase.) I only started (reluctantly!) using credit cards again after a big problem with my debit card.
What’s changed?
It’s not HOW I’m paying for things. It’s how I FEEL when I’m paying for things. In other words, it’s my attitude and my rediscovered ability to exercise self-control.
That’s what’s important. Personally, I think people should do what’s right for them. Although hard-core “you spend more when you use credit” people probably won’t believe me, I don’t spend more when I use credit.
For me, using a credit card is the painful thing. It HURTS. Every time I go to pay for something with my credit card, I remember how painful owing money on those things was. I remember that I’m never going to be there again. And, I get to experience the pain of spending the money not just once like when I hand over cash, but four times. (Once when I make the purchase, once when I enter it into Quicken, once when I write it in my spreadsheet, and once when I transfer the money to my credit card account.)
For many people, cash is the painful thing, and that works for them. Others probably have never had a problem with self-control in that area, and so it doesn’t matter which they use. They are already always thoughtful about their money choices.
I could be just as thoughtful about cash as I am about credit. It’s a mind trick or a way of viewing things. But I have chosen to view cash as blow money that doesn’t need to be accounted for except in a general way. As a result, I hardly ever carry cash, because I don’t like to blow money. I never really realized til now that I was actually just doing some mental gymnastics.
However you get there, it’s thinking about your spending and making sure it’s working for you and getting the results you want that matters.
Related Websites- How to Pay Off Your Card Credit cards create for their users a cycle which is vicious: charging for items when you do not have the money, and then finding it...
- Give me some credit, or not f you have not checked out Trent's blog, now is the time to get started. This guy has that "I've been through it style" that...
- Top 5 Ways To Go Broke Ever wonder why some people go absolutely broke. Not like Donald Trump who had a negative net worth of a Billion Dollars but still lived...



March 23rd, 2009 at 7:19 am
I like your your post and I definitely learned a thing or two in using my credit card. I agree with you when you say self control. Its a must when you have a credit card.
March 23rd, 2009 at 9:29 am
I think a lot of people who do not use credit cards are afraid of the cards. They do not have the self control it takes to make a budget and then use the card within that budget to get things and then pay off the card.
I use my credit cards for all purchases because I get cash back on the cards. I pay the card off in full every month…..so no balance means no fees but I still get 1-5% cash back on purchases…so I make money using my cards.
I stick to my budget…I have $25 for clothes for the month…so if I buy one shirt then I can’t spend any more. I don’t look at the card as an extension of the $25.
March 23rd, 2009 at 9:43 am
It’s all about learning from mistakes and doing what works for you. I am able to use both cash and credit responsibly.
March 23rd, 2009 at 6:01 pm
I stopped using credit cards awhile ago, largely for the same reasons you mention. However, I do all I can to avoid using them now not because of a sense of fear or lack of self-control, but because I think it is a wretched industry with some alarming unethical and exploitative practices. There are cards available from companies that utilize ethical business practices, are not predatory in their lending, and even donate to worthwhile causes. At some point, I may venture back into credit card land with one of those specialty cards. But until then, the credit card industry (at least in my little universe) can suck it.
March 23rd, 2009 at 9:07 pm
Huh, CF, I didn’t know there were cards like that…
March 24th, 2009 at 7:49 pm
Thanks for the link-love.
One thing… I could, very easily, go right back to credit cards, and we’d do just fine. I’ve learned to control my spending, and I live on a budget. That being said, I just don’t like the darn things, and I believe that living cash-only (w/ occasional debit card use and writing a few checks) keeps me IN TOUCH w/ our finances.
March 26th, 2009 at 12:23 pm
Blunt $$– Green America (formerly Co-Op America) has a page dedicated to credit cards that are more socially responsible than the average bear. I can’t swear by any of them, ‘cuz I haven’t ventured there yet (one day!), but if you’re curious, here’s the link: http://www.coopamerica.org/pubs/realmoney/articles/ResponsibleCreditCards.cfm